-
Sunday, July 5, 2020
Home Technology Fake news of Celebrity crypto scam on Facebook; Dutch courts asks to...

Fake news of Celebrity crypto scam on Facebook; Dutch courts asks to remove those

A Dutch court has ruled that Facebook can be required to use filter technologies to identify and pre-emptively take down fake ads linked to crypto currency scams that carry the image of a media personality, John de Mol, and other well known celebrities.

The Dutch celebrity filed a lawsuit against Facebook in April over the misappropriation of his and other celebrities’ likeness to shill Bitcoin scams via fake ads run on its platform.

In an immediately enforceable preliminary judgement today, the court has ordered Facebook to remove all offending ads within five days, and provide data on the accounts running them within a week.

As per the judgement, victims of the crypto scams had reported a total of €1.7 million (~$1.8M) in damages to the Dutch government at the time of the court summons.

The case is similar to a legal action instigated by UK consumer advice personality, Martin Lewis, last year, when he announced defamation proceedings against Facebook — also for misuse of his image in fake ads for crypto scams. Lewis withdrew the suit at the start of this year after Facebook agreed to apply new measures to tackle the problem: Namely a scam ads report button. It also agreed to provide funding to a UK consumer advice organization to set up a scam advice service.

In the de Mol case, the lawsuit was allowed to run its course — resulting in today’s preliminary judgement against Facebook.

It’s not yet clear whether the company will appeal but, in the wake of the ruling Facebook has said it will bring the scam ads report button to the Dutch market early next month.

In court, the platform giant sought to argue that it could not more proactively remove the Bitcoin scam ads containing celebrities’ images on the grounds that doing so would breach EU law against general monitoring conditions being placed on Internet platforms.

However the court rejected that argument, citing a recent ruling by Europe’s top court related to platform obligations to remove hate speech, also concluding that the specificity of the requested measures could not be classified as ‘general obligations of supervision’.

It also rejected arguments by Facebook’s lawyers that restricting the fake scam ads would be restricting the freedom of expression of a natural person, or the right to be freely informed — pointing out that the ‘expressions’ involved are aimed at commercial gain, as well as including fraudulent practices.

Facebook also sought to argue it is already doing all it can to identify and take down the fake scam ads — saying too that its screening processes are not perfect. But the court said there’s no requirement for 100% effectiveness for additional proactive measures to be ordered.

Its ruling further notes a striking reduction in fake scam ads using de Mol’s image since the lawsuit was announced

Facebook’s argument that it’s just a neutral platform was also rejected, with the court pointing out that its core business is advertising. It also took the view that requiring Facebook to apply technically complicated measures and extra effort, including in terms of manpower and costs, to more effectively remove offending scam ads is not unreasonable in this context.

The judgement orders Facebook to remove fake scam ads containing celebrity likenesses from Facebook and Instagram within five days of the order — with a penalty of €10k per day that Facebook fails to comply with the order, up to a maximum of €1M (~$1.1M).

The court order also requires that Facebook provides data to the affected celebrity on the accounts that had been misusing their likeness within seven days of the judgement, with a further penalty of €1k per day for failure to comply, up to a maximum of €100k.

Facebook has also been ordered to pay the case costs.

Responding to the judgement in a statement, a Facebook spokesperson told us:

We have just received the ruling and will now look at its implications. We will consider all legal actions, including appeal. Importantly, this ruling does not change our commitment to fighting these types of ads. We cannot stress enough that these types of ads have absolutely no place on Facebook and we remove them when we find them. We take this very seriously and will therefore make our scam ads reporting form available in the Netherlands in early December. This is an additional way to get feedback from people, which in turn helps train our machine learning models. It is in our interest to protect our users from fraudsters and when we find violators we will take action to stop their activity, up to and including taking legal action against them in court.

One legal expert describes the judgement as “pivotal“. Law professor Mireille Hildebrandt told us that it provides for as an alternative legal route for Facebook users to litigate and pursue collective enforcement of European personal data rights. Rather than suing for damages — which entails a high burden of proof.

Injunctions are faster and more effective, Hildebrandt added.

The judgement also raises questions around the burden of proof for demonstrating Facebook has removed scam ads with sufficient (increased) accuracy; and what specific additional measures it might deploy to improve its takedown rate.

Although the introduction of the ‘report scam ad button’ does provide one clear avenue for measuring takedown performance.

The button was finally rolled out to the UK market in July. And while Facebook has talked since the start of this year about ‘envisaging’ introducing it in other markets it hasn’t exactly been proactive in doing so — up til now, with this court order. 

Avatar
Chaitanya Kayandehttp://vyapaarJagat.com
Chaitanya is a weird combination of Engineering, Journalism and Poetry. Out of everything in the world, he loves chai (tea), monsoon, trekking, travelling and writing the most! Read and enjoy his raw and authentic writing 🙂

Stay Connected

5,715FansLike
4,224FollowersFollow
1,288FollowersFollow
3,989FollowersFollow
1,267FollowersFollow
6,453SubscribersSubscribe

Must Read

Andrew Forrest Biography: Success Story of Fortescue Metals Group CEO

In this success post, we are going to share the story of Andrew Forrest, born in 1961. He is a mining magnate...

Asia’s unique and first virtual 3 days summit, “WOMEN MILLIONAIRE SUMMIT 2020” on 24th – 26th July 2020

Billennium Divas Private Limited, Women India Network, Digitise Factory Pvt. Ltd and Pinks Event together teams up to create and organize Asia's...

Sunil Mittal Biography: Success Story of Airtel CEO

In this success post, we are going to share the story of Sunil Mittal, an Indian entrepreneur who founded the Bharti Enterprises,...

Following passion leads Vigneshwaran to his destiny from nowhere to the world of records

Mr. Vigneshwaran is Founder and CEO of Nandha Infotech and holds the record for Creating 153 Web Applications Developed in 10 hours...

Related News

Andrew Forrest Biography: Success Story of Fortescue Metals Group CEO

In this success post, we are going to share the story of Andrew Forrest, born in 1961. He is a mining magnate...

Asia’s unique and first virtual 3 days summit, “WOMEN MILLIONAIRE SUMMIT 2020” on 24th – 26th July 2020

Billennium Divas Private Limited, Women India Network, Digitise Factory Pvt. Ltd and Pinks Event together teams up to create and organize Asia's...

Sunil Mittal Biography: Success Story of Airtel CEO

In this success post, we are going to share the story of Sunil Mittal, an Indian entrepreneur who founded the Bharti Enterprises,...

Following passion leads Vigneshwaran to his destiny from nowhere to the world of records

Mr. Vigneshwaran is Founder and CEO of Nandha Infotech and holds the record for Creating 153 Web Applications Developed in 10 hours...

Charles Butt Biography: Success Story of HEB supermarket CEO

In this success post, we are going to share the story of Charles Butt, an American businessman, best known for the HEB...

Language »
×

Hello!

Click one of our representatives below to chat on WhatsApp or send us an email to [email protected]

×